The Difference Between Horror and Fright

When Halloween rolls around, and I start sifting through my collection of scary movies and stories, I start realizing that most of our so-called scary works today fall into the secondary definition of horror, “intense aversion or repugnance,” rather than truly inducing fright.

What on earth do I mean?

Well, specifically I’m thinking of the “torture porn” movies that pervade our cinema today, and the True Blood school of horror, in which filmmakers must constantly up the ante in order to make us gasp with, well, horror.

Truly scary movies need to make me jump at small noises, not jump up to run to the toilet so that I can vomit after witnessing fountains of blood. Truly scary books need to make me so frightened I can’t close the book because the real world could be even scarier.

It’s the difference between this:

Nothing like ripping out a newscaster’s spine on live TV. 

And this:

This scene was removed from the original version of The Exorcist. Seriously.

One inspires shock and a shudder, the other inspires shock and a shiver. I didn’t stay up worrying that Russell Edgington was going to come into my home and rip out my spine. Nope, I stayed up having visions of a grotesque Regan MacNeil sitting at the foot of my bed.

The Exorcist is, I think, scarier because it happens in a quiet, suburban setting. Any kid could get possessed, but I don’t think the Vampire King of Louisiana is likely to exist any time soon. That’s the trick to truly frightening people: making them fear for themselves as well as for your main characters.

What are some works of film and fiction that have truly frightened you? 

Happy Halloween, everyone!

3 thoughts on “The Difference Between Horror and Fright

  1. Stephen King’s ‘IT’ was super creepy. It was a seriously good read. I’ve seen the film too but the book is still the best. And ‘The Rats’ by James Herbert also left me feeling uneasy for quite some time after. Those are the ones that stick in my head.

  2. Shauna Granger says:

    I fully agree; slashers do nothing for me but make me cringe and hide my face because of the gross factor. Movies that play with my mind, like ghost stories, now those get me hiding under the protection of my covers!

  3. Ah, yes! The difference between Texas Chainsaw Massacre and The Sixth Sense, for instance. And that scene from The Exorcist seriously gave me the creeps. I couldn’t believe what I was seeing when I saw it! I’d heard it had been cut, but WOW. I love that movie. 🙂

Show Us Some Love!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s